Home > History > Historic Places

Historic Places in Ontario County

Adelaide Avenue School

108-116 Adelaide Ave.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Orlando K. Foote

Style: Queen Anne

Period: 1850-1874

Ownership: Private

Ashcroft

112 Jay St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Calvert Vaux

Style: Gothic Revival

Period: 1850-1874

Ownership: Private

Levi Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse

5300 Wabash Rd.

Town of Seneca

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Not listed

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1924

Ownership: Private

Thomas Barron House

1160 Canandaigua Rd. (Rts. 5 & 20)

Town of Seneca

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Thomas Barron

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1949

Ownership: Private

Belhurst Castle

Lochland Rd.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Albert W. Fuller

Style: Romanesque

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

Note: Not your typical bed & breakfast.

Benham House

280-282 S. Main St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Italianate

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

Boughton Hill (Gannagaro Site)

Holcomb-Victor Rd.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Seneca

Style: Aboriginal

Period: 1650-1699

Ownership: Private, State

Note: See the history of this area. Designated a National Historic Landmark.

Brigham Hall (Grove Home)

229 Bristol St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1850-1949

Ownership: Private

Unnamed Building

426 South Main St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Renaissance, Italianate

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

Canandaigua Historic District

Main St. from Chapel to Saltonstall Sts., Howell, Gibson, Gorham, Bristol, Bemis, and Center Sts.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Various

Style: Greek Revival, Italianate

Period: 1800-1949

Ownership: Private

Thaddeus Chapin House

128 Thad Chapin St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Federal

Period: 1800-1824

Ownership: Private

Ephraim Cleveland House

201 N. Main St.

Naples, NY 14512

Architect: Unknown

Style: Federal

Period: 1750-1849

Ownership: Private

Historic Significance: Associated with Ephraim Cleveland. If true, the story of Ephraim Cleveland is an interesting one. Born in 1740 in Connecticut, he became a captain. (It's unclear whether this was in the British Army or a local militia.) He was captured by Indians and held captive for three years, at which point he escaped. He later fought in the Revolutionary War. For whom is unclear but perhaps for the Colonists as he and a fellow named Mark Watkins were captured by Indians, many of whom supported the British. These Indians pulled out all Cleveland's and Watkins' hair and tied them to stakes. As the Indians were preparing to burn the men alive, a squaw whose son had been killed in the war, asked for the men in "payment" for her dead son. (This "exchange" was a common practice among the Indians and often meant enslavement for the exchangee.) Cleveland's hair never grew back, and he wore an eel-skin cap to cover his head from then on. After a time, he and Watkins gained the trust of the tribe and were allowed to go hunting alone, at which point they took the opportunity to escape. Around 1783 he made his way to Ontario County and settled in Naples Flats. He is considered one of the founding fathers of Naples and lived there until he died, sometime between 1820 and 1827.

Clifton Springs Sanitarium (The Spa Apartments and Foster Cottage Museum)

9 & 11 E. Main St.

Clifton Springs , NY 14432

Architect: Pierce & Bickford

Style: Romanesque, Gothic Revival

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

Historic Significance: Associated with Dr. Henry Foster. See more information about Dr. Foster and the sanitarium, as well as a photo of the cottage.

Clifton Springs Sanitarium Historic District

E. Main St. between Crane and Prospect

Clifton Springs, NY 14432

Architect: Pierce & Bickford

Style: Classical Revival, Romanesque, Gothic Revival

Period: 1850-1949

Ownership: Private

Cobblestone Manor

495 N. Main St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

Cobblestone Railroad Pumphouse

Main St.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Unknown

Style: Mid 19th Century Revival

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

Jeremiah Cronkite House

1095 Lynaugh Rd.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Not listed

Style: Federal

Period: 1825-1924

Ownership: Local Govt.

East Bloomfield Historic District

Main, South, & Park Sts. and Rt. 5

East Bloomfield, NY 14443

Architect: Unknown

Style: Mid 19th Century Revival, Late Victorian, Federal

Period: 1900-1949

Ownership: Private, Local Govt.

Felt Cobblestone General Store

6452 Victor Manchester Rd.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

First Baptist Church

134 N. Main St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: H.M. Hubbard

Style: Romanesque

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

First Baptist Church of Phelps

40 Church St.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: John Skinner, Stephen Trumbull

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

Genesee Park Historic District

Genesee Park Pl. and Genesee & Lewis Sts.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Not listed

Style: Mid 19th Century Revival, Late Victorian

Period: 1825-1924

Ownership: Private, Local Govt.

Geneva Armory

300 Main St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Isaac Perry, George Heins

Style: Late Victorian

Period: 1875-1924

Ownership: State

Geneva Hall and Trinity Hall

Hobart & William Smith College

S. Main St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Benjamin Hale

Style: Not listed

Period: 1800-1849

Ownership: Private

Granger Cottage

60 Granger St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Colonial Revival, Gothic Revival

Period: 1850-1924

Ownership: Private

Francis Granger House

426 N. Main St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Federal

Period: 1800-1824

Ownership: Private

Harmon Cobblestone Farmhouse and Cobblestone Smokehouse

983 Smith Rd.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

Dr. John Quincy Howe House

66 Main St.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: Moses Barlow

Style: Second Empire

Period: 1850-1924

Ownership: Private

Note: Home of the Phelps Community Historical Society. Built of red brick in 1869 on a site previously been used by a tavern and a tinsmithing shop, the Howe House has a two-story privy with 3 holes on each floor. This is probably the only 2-story privy in the state. Quite a claim to fame. See an article on two-story privies and a photo of the Howe House privy. The Historical Society is listed online.

William Huffman Cobblestone House

1064 Townline Rd.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: Not listed

Style: Greek Revival

Period:1825-1924

Ownership: Private

Marshall House

274 Bristol St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Italianate, Federal

Period: 1825-1849

Ownership: Private

Morgan Hook and Ladder Company

18-20 Mill St.

Naples, NY 14512

Architect: Unknown

Style: Federal, Late Victorian

Period: 1825-1949

Ownership: Private

Naples Memorial Town Hall

N. Main St.

Naples, NY 14512

Architect: Seymour H. Sutton, E.W. Buck, et al.

Style: Italianate

Period: 1850-1924

Ownership: Local Govt.

Nester House (Geneva On The Lake)

1001 Lochland Rd.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Louis Colt Albro, Harrie T. Lindeberg

Style: Renaissance

Period: 1900-1924

Ownership: Private

North Main Street Historic District

Between RR tracks and Buffalo-Chapel St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival, Late Victorian, Federal

Period: 1800-1899

Ownership: Private, Local Govt.

Osborne House

146 Maple Ave.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Austin & Warner

Style: Italian Villa

Period: 1850-1874

Ownership: Private

Parrott Hall (Denton House, Denton Place)

643 North St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Unknown

Style: Italian Villa

Period: 1850-1899

Ownership: State

Note: Parrott Hall is part of the New York State Agricultural Experiment Station under the direction of Cornell University. Built in 1882, it is named for Dr. Percival J. Parrott, entomologist and former director of the Station.

Phelps Town Hall

79 Main St.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: John Bloomer & Son, J. Foster Warner, et al.

Style: Greek Revival, Classical Revival

Period: 1825-1924

Ownership: Local Govt.

Port Gibson United Methodist Church

2951 Greig St.

Port Gibson, NY 14537

Architect: Unknown

Style: Romanesque

Period: 1850-1874

Ownership: Private

Rippey Cobblestone Farmhouse

1227 Leet Rd.

Town of Seneca

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Unknown

Style: Greek Revival, Italianate

Period: 1850-1874

Ownership: Private

Saltonstall Street School

47 Saltonstall St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Orlando K. Foote, Albion Ellis

Style: Queen Anne

Period: 1850-1899

Ownership: Private

Seneca Presbyterian Church (Number Nine Road Church)

4362 Number Nine Rd.

Stanley, NY 14561

Architect: Unknown

Style: Not listed

Period: 1825-1899

Ownership: Private

Smith Opera House

82 Seneca St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Joseph Pierce, Henry Bickford

Style: Richardsonian Romanesque

Period: 1875-1900

Ownership: Not listed

Sonnenberg Gardens

151 Charlotte St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Ernest Bowditch, K. Wadamori

Style: Various

Period: 1875-1924

Ownership: Private

South Bristol Grange Hall 1107

6457 Rt. 64

Hamlet of Bristol Springs

Naples, NY 14512

Architect: Not listed

Style: Late 19th and Early 20th Century American

Period: 1900-1924

Ownership: Private

South Main Street Historic District

Irregular pattern along S. Main St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Various

Style: Late 19th and 20th Century Revivals, Greek Revivals, Late Victorian

Period: 1800-1899

Ownership: Private, Local Govt.

St. Bridget's Roman Catholic Church Complex

15 Church St. between Church and Michigan Sts.

Bloomfield, NY 14469

Architect: Neenan Bros.

Style: Colonial Revival, Italianate

Period: 1850-1949

Ownership: Private

St. John's Episcopal Church (Phelps Village Library)

Church St.

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: Maj. David B. Douglass

Style: Gothic Revival

Period: 1825-1874

Ownership: Local Govt.

St. Peter's Episcopal Church

44 Main St.

Bloomfield, NY 14469

Architect: S.P. Hastings

Style: Not listed

Period: 1850-1899

Ownership: Private

Philetus Swift House

866 State Rt. 96

Phelps, NY 14532

Architect: unknown

Style: unknown

Period: unknown

Ownership: private

U.S. Post Office

28 N. Main St.

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Allen & Collens

Style: Classical Revival

Period: 1900-1949

Ownership: Federal

U.S. Post Office

67 Castle St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: James Knox Taylor, Louis A. Simon

Style: Colonial Revival

Period: 1900-1949

Ownership: Federal

Valentown Hall (Valentown Museum)

7377 Valentown Sq.

Victor, NY 14564

Architect: Not listed

Style: Not listed

Period: 1875-1899

Ownership: Private

Note: See more information about the hall and a photo.

Oliver Warner Farmstead

Rt. 88

Clifton Springs, NY 14432

Architect: Oliver Warner

Style: Greek Revival, Federal

Period: 1825-1899

Ownership: Private

Washington Street Cemetery

Washington St.

Geneva, NY 14456

Architect: Not listed

Style: Not listed

Period: 1825-1949

Ownership: Private

George Wheeler House

6353 Grimble Rd.

Town of East Bloomfield

Canandaigua, NY 14424

Architect: Unknown

Style: Unknown

Period: Unknown

Ownership: Private

Wilder Cemetery

Rt. 64

Town of Bristol

Naples, NY 14512

Architect: Not listed

Style: Not listed

Period: 1800-1924

Ownership: Private

 

 

 

Advertise

on
ILovetheFingerLakes

 

 

Your ad could go here!

 

Your ad could go here!

 

Your ad could go here!